Pin it
My latest kitchen adventure turned a classic cheeseburger into the most comforting bowl of soup you can imagine. After countless requests for dairy-free recipes from my blog readers I created this Paleo version that brings all those juicy burger flavors right into your spoon. The first time I served this to my family they couldn't believe it was dairy-free.
More Than Just Another Soup
There's something magical about transforming familiar flavors into something new. This one-pot wonder brings together crispy bacon ground beef and my secret cashew cheese sauce into a bowl that tastes just like biting into your favorite burger. My son actually prefers it to regular cheeseburgers now which still amazes me.
Everything You'll Need
- Bacon: Four slices of your favorite bacon. I get mine from the local butcher shop it makes such a difference.
- Ground Beef: A pound of good quality beef. Grass-fed gives the best flavor.
- Onion: One medium onion finely chopped. Sweet onions work beautifully here.
- Potatoes: Two medium ones peeled and diced. They make the soup so hearty.
- Tomatoes: One can of diced tomatoes adds that perfect burger sauce taste.
- Seasonings: Simple garlic powder and sea salt let the main ingredients shine.
- Cashews: These create the creamiest dairy-free cheese sauce you'll ever taste.
- Nutritional Yeast: My secret weapon for that cheesy flavor without dairy.
- Special Touches: Tomato paste mustard and pickle juice these make it taste just like a real burger.
Let's Start Cooking
Start by cooking your bacon until it's perfectly crispy. I love doing this in my cast iron skillet handed down from my grandmother. The kitchen starts smelling amazing as those bacon slices sizzle. Don't even think about throwing away that gorgeous bacon fat we'll use it to cook our beef making everything even more flavorful.
Building Our Base
Now comes the beef in that same pan with all those bacon drippings. Break it up with your spoon and let it brown until it's cooked through. My daughter always sneaks a few pieces while I'm cooking they smell that good. Set your beef aside and keep all those tasty bits in the bottom of your pan.
Adding More Goodness
Those diced onions and potatoes go right into the same pan. Watch as they start to soften and become translucent soaking up all those wonderful flavors from the meat. This is when my kitchen really starts to feel like a cozy neighborhood diner.
Pin it
Creating the Soup Base
Time to add your tomatoes broth and seasonings. The way everything comes together as it simmers is pure kitchen magic. Your house will smell incredible and don't be surprised if neighbors start dropping by to ask what's cooking.
The Magic Cheese Sauce
Here's where we make our dairy-free cheese sauce and trust me nobody will believe it's not real cheese. Those soaked cashews blend up into the creamiest sauce especially with our special additions of nutritional yeast pickle juice and mustard. It's my favorite kitchen trick.
Bringing It All Together
After about 15 minutes of gentle simmering, pour in your cheese sauce and add back that beautiful browned beef. Watch how everything swirls together into the most inviting soup. Sometimes I find myself just standing over the pot taking in that incredible aroma. This is when my family starts circling the kitchen asking when dinner will be ready.
Time to Serve
Now comes my favorite part serving this beautiful creation. I love setting out little bowls of toppings like the crispy bacon bits chopped lettuce and diced pickles. Everyone gets to customize their bowl just like they would their perfect burger. My husband always adds extra bacon while my kids fight over the last pickle.
Saving Some for Later
If you're lucky enough to have leftovers they'll keep beautifully in the fridge for a week. I often make a double batch on Sunday to enjoy throughout the week. The flavors actually get even better after a day or two just like a good homemade soup should.
Pin it
Making It Your Own
Want to keep things low-carb? I've made this countless times with cauliflower or jicama instead of potatoes. They work wonderfully and keep that satisfying texture we all love. My sister who follows keto absolutely adores this version.
Mix It Up
Some nights I switch things up using ground turkey or chicken. Last week I added mushrooms and spinach it was divine. That's what I love about cooking you can always make a recipe your own. My readers often send me photos of their creative variations.
Add Some Heat
For those who love a kick of spice try adding some diced jalapeños or a splash of hot sauce. My husband's favorite version includes chipotle peppers which add such a lovely smoky heat. The best recipes are the ones you can play with.
Good for You Too
This soup isn't just delicious it's actually quite nourishing. Packed with protein from the beef healthy fats from the cashews and whatever veggies you choose to add it's a complete meal in a bowl. Even my nutrition-conscious friends ask for seconds.
My Best Kitchen Tips
When it comes to that cashew sauce the secret is patience. I soak my cashews overnight which gives them that perfect creamy texture when blended. Sometimes I'll even blend it twice to get that silky smoothness. Play around with the seasonings too each time you make it let your taste buds guide you. Just yesterday I discovered that adding a touch more pickle juice made everyone smile even bigger.
Learning From Experience
Through years of making this soup I've learned to watch those potatoes carefully. They should be fork tender but not falling apart. Another lesson from my kitchen timing is everything. Let those flavors meld together while simmering don't rush the process. Your patience will be rewarded with the most incredible depth of flavor.
Your Questions Answered
After sharing this recipe on my blog I've received so many wonderful questions. Yes you can absolutely make it ahead for busy weeknights. Many of my readers prep it on Sunday for easy weekday dinners. If cashews aren't your thing sunflower seeds make a wonderful alternative I discovered this when cooking for my nephew with nut allergies. And freezing? This soup freezes beautifully I often make an extra batch to tuck away for those nights when cooking isn't in the cards.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why soak the cashews?
Soaking cashews in boiling water softens them, making them blend into a smoother, creamier sauce.
- → Is this really dairy-free?
Yes, it uses cashews and nutritional yeast to create a creamy, cheese-like flavor without any dairy products.
- → What makes it Whole30 compliant?
All ingredients are whole foods with no dairy, grains, legumes, or artificial additives.
- → Can I skip the nutritional yeast?
While it adds cheese-like flavor, you can omit it. The soup will still be creamy but less cheesy tasting.
- → Can I use different potatoes?
Yes, but Yukon golds are recommended for their buttery texture and ability to hold shape in soup.